Sheriff: ‘There are no winners’ in standoff outcome
by Megan Thornton
mthornton@cherokeetribune.com
May 05, 2012 12:00 AM | 4426 views | 11 11 comments | 11 11 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Sheriff Roger Garrison <br>Cherokee Tribune/File
Sheriff Roger Garrison
Cherokee Tribune/File
slideshow
TOWNE LAKE — For the Messina family, Tuesday night began with a family argument but ended with the shooting death of their son during a standoff with deputies.

Sixteen-year-old Andrew Messina died from a single shot fired by a sheriff’s deputy after the troubled youth threatened suicide, held his mom at gunpoint and attempted to set fire to their home.

Funeral services are set for the youth on Monday at 4 p.m. at Hillside United Methodist Church. Visitation is Sunday from 5 to 9 p.m. at Woodstock Funeral Home Chapel.

Members of the community have continued to weigh in on the tragic event while those close to Andrew and deputies with the Cherokee County Sheriff’s Office who were on the scene attempt to deal with the aftermath.

Sheriff Roger Garrison said Friday he met with the Messinas the previous day to discuss the events that led a sniper to shoot the Etowah High School sophomore after an hour-long standoff with negotiators at his home in the Eagle Watch subdivision.

“I mostly listened to the father and (both of) their concerns,” Garrison said. “I was able to explain some of the reasons we did the things we did.”

In the midst of an argument with his mother around 6 p.m. Tuesday, the boy wearing a John Lennon T-shirt and blue nylon shorts grabbed his father’s .357 Magnum and began threatening to harm himself and his mother, according to 911 tapes.

Based on information provided to authorities by his mother, the teen was on a combination of medications for depression and had been drinking alcohol.

Just over an hour after Andrew’s mother called 911, authorities say the teen broke a glass window pane in the front door and pointed the gun toward sheriff’s deputies which led a sniper to take a single, fatal shot to the boy’s abdomen. He later died at WellStar Kennestone Hospital in Marietta.

Garrison said his Wednesday meeting with the Messinas was emotional, as he tried to provide the grieving parents answers to difficult questions surrounding the incident.

“(The father) was able to get things off his chest,” Garrison said. “They lost a child. I spoke to tell them that if the situation were reversed, I would most likely feel exactly the way they feel.”

Yet Garrison said he felt the meeting was positive because it opened the lines of communication and he was able to let the parents know that everyone in the department wished for a different outcome.

“It was no outcome we would ever hope for,” he said. “Our negotiators worked feverishly, to the very, very best of their abilities to establish rapport with Andrew and it’s just a very tragic situation. There are no winners.”

Garrison said his office will continue to offer counseling to employees.

“This has hit a number of people very hard,” he said. “It’s nothing anybody takes lightly and it’s the most dreaded portion of our jobs. We’re dealing with it the best we can.”

After a few days to reflect, Garrison said there wasn’t anything he would have done differently in the situation, despite the flood of controversy surrounding the case.

He does not anticipate getting any new information regarding the investigation from the Georgia Bureau of Investigation for several weeks.

“At some point in time, we will do an after-action report and if there’s anything we feel we need to adjust, we’d certainly be open to adjusting that,” he said.

Obituary information from the family stated that Andrew was a “true artist, vocalist and poet” with a passion for the rights of animals and a defender of his beliefs in humanity.

“(Andrew) was always thinking of others and put his family and friends above his own interests,” the obituary states. “As we look back at his short time on this earth, his passing will leave a void in all of our lives but his memory will always bring a smile and comfort to all.”

Survivors include his parents, Nicholas and Lisa Antonucci Messina of Woodstock; his godparents Richard and Melanie Thompson of Woodstock; three aunts and several cousins.

The family requests instead of flowers donations be made to Our Pals Place at 4508 Canton Road in Marietta. Online condolences may be made at www.woodstockfuneralhome.com.

Comments
(11)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
also a mom
|
May 08, 2012
Why is there not more outrage that a gun was available in the house that a troubled teen had access to? It is a tragedy, but unfortunately the parents bear some of the responsibility. The mother felt threatened enough to call 911. It is unfair to now persecute those she called for help.
just a mom
|
May 07, 2012
I just watched the parents on the news . I think soon our police all over the nation will be afaid to do the job that needs to be done. Even if young Andrew did not threaten his mom she still had to call them. I feel for our police department (soon we will have no police because they are afraid to do what has to be done!)
anonymous
|
May 07, 2012
The police murdered this poor kid, the parents have every right to be upset. They just needed to back off and give him a chance to cool down. There was no one in the house, he could have only harmed himself.
Bob Zuwicki
|
October 28, 2012
Why did the police cut the phone line to the house while the boy was speaking with his father? Why not let the father talk the boy out of it? Why send a "sniper" into the house?
Concerned Voter
|
May 06, 2012
Chanel 2 News should show the first interview with the family tonight.

Get the truth instead of all the fabrications and coverup from the Sheriff.
just a mom
|
May 05, 2012
After doing a lot of thinking about this. I have said before I am a mom of a young man with bipoler and anger issues. The only thing that could have been done differntly in this whole sittuation is to HAVE NO GUNS IN THE HOME! There would not have been a reason to shoot this boy is he had not had a gun. For anyone else outthere with children in your home that could hurt anyone JUST DONT HAVE A GUN IN YOUR HOME. Sure they get hurt other ways but a gun gives the police a reason to take action.
Jackson Heights
|
October 28, 2012
The mother could not have NOT called the police.
anonymous
|
May 05, 2012
This is a tragedy. What I don't understand is why the family would have a gun available in the home with a troubled teen. If he didn't have access to a gun this could have had a completely different outcome.
Just a mom
|
May 05, 2012
I feel for this poor mom. She did what she had to do. Please Mrs. Messina dont blame yourself. You had no choice. It was a sittuaton that could have turned even worse. I am a parent of a young man that had anger problems from being bipolar. I think this could have been him. I would have done the same thing you did. And the police did the only thing they could have done.

Time for Adjustment
|
May 05, 2012
"if there’s anything we feel we need to adjust, we’d certainly be open to adjusting that” I'd like to propose we make an adjustment in leadership at the sheriff's office in November.

Concerned Voter
|
May 06, 2012
A change has to happen.

When these lies, exaggerations, and deceptions are all exposed you will all understand why we need change.
*We welcome your comments on the stories and issues of the day and seek to provide a forum for the community to voice opinions. All comments are subject to moderator approval before being made visible on the website but are not edited. The use of profanity, obscene and vulgar language, hate speech, and racial slurs is strictly prohibited. Advertisements, promotions, spam, and links to outside websites will also be rejected. Please read our terms of service for full guides