Cherokee schools review cost-cutting ideas
by Kristal Dixon
kdixon@cherokeetribune.com
January 23, 2010 01:00 AM | 2783 views | 11 11 comments | 22 22 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Bracing for another tough budget year, the Cherokee County school board is eyeing a long list of cost-saving measures.

The board at its work session Thursday night reviewed proposals from the school district staff that range from continuing class-size waivers to trimming art, music, physical education and special education programs.

Other ideas on the table include: switching to a half-day kindergarten; increasing the size of special education and gifted classes; making cuts or charging fees for student activity and athletic programs; trimming transportation services for the regular school year and summer school; reducing the school nursing staff, safety and security expenditures and maintenance contracts; skipping the purchase of new textbooks; and raising fees for the use of school facilities.

County Superintendent of Schools Dr. Frank Petruzielo said if these cuts come to pass, they will be met with frustration.

"None of these are going to be met with wide applause by parents," he said. "When the money is not there to provide those services, then something's got to give."

In light of Gov. Sonny Perdue's recommendations that school systems make mid-year cuts to the school nurse program, Petruzielo said the district has no choice but to do so.

"We'll immediately make the adjustments as necessary," he said.

The district employs 47 school nurses for its 40 schools.

The decision to not purchase new textbooks for the upcoming school year would be the first time the district has done so in 10 years, Petruzielo said.

Also, with Perdue's announcement that teachers should take three furlough days during the next five-and-a-half months, Petruzielo recommended Jan. 8 and 11 be counted as two of them. On those days, the schools were closed because of the ice storm.

The proposal was approved by the board. The financial impact of the loss of those days' pay would occur between February and June, and the amount would depend on an employee's salary schedule.

Upon Petruzielo's recommendation, the board pulled $1.9 million from the district's reserves to prevent a third furlough day for all employees.

The use of the $1.9 million would add to the $8 million-hit the district's reserves have already taken in the last 18 months, Petruzielo said. The district currently has about $37 million in its reserves.

"We're already in pretty dangerous territory," he added.

District staff took three furlough days last semester as recommended by Perdue.

Board member Kim Cochran at Thursday's meeting inquired what the impact of furloughs has been on teachers' salaries.

Based on a first-year teacher with a bachelor's degree making the starting salary of $41,500, he or she would lose $1,092 in pay as a result of the five furlough days so far this school year.

Petruzielo said the district will continue to leave six coordinator and supervisor positions vacant in the coming budget year and not make any changes to its organizational chart. Those six positions, he said, have been vacant for two years.

Along with not filling those positions, some teachers-on-special-assignment at the district central office may be moved back into the classroom to fill teaching positions.

Also to help relieve the cost of transportation, the district will not purchase any new school buses next year. Petruzielo said the district staff will look as well at tweaking bus routes in an effort to cut down on fuel usage.

Board members said they were appreciative of the superintendent's and cabinet members' efforts on proposing cuts that would have the least impact possible on classroom learning.

"I appreciate the folks sharpening their pencils on this," board member Janet Read said.

Board Chairwoman Debi Radcliff added this year "will be a difficult year" for the school system.

Board member Mike Chapman additionally outlined ways he thought the district could also further cut costs.

Chapman, who used the manufacturing plant he manages as an example, said it would be wise for the district to "think outside the box" to come up with ways of saving money. These, he said, could include monitoring heating and air conditioning usage, cutting down on paper usage and being meticulous in negotiating vendor contracts to purchase things at the lowest price possible.

"We need to have every teacher and employee-focused on cutting cost," he added.

Petruzielo said the district staff has already taken these steps, adding it was unfair to compare the school system's budget to a business model.

"Unlike your business, we are treated as though we can balance our budget on a miracle," he said. "I hope the public doesn't get the perception that these things haven't been addressed."

In other business, the board approved an $18.7-million contract with Hardin Construction Company to build a replacement elementary school in Ball Ground.

The board voted 6-0-1, with Mrs. Radcliff abstaining because of a potential conflict of interest, to approve the contract, which was the second lowest out of 10 proposals submitted.

The school, which is located within the city limits, will have a 1,200-student capacity and use the same design as the replacement Little River and Canton Elementary Schools.

The 146,403-square-foot building will sit on 25 acres and have 74 classrooms, a media center, computer labs, a gymnasium and art and music rooms. Manley, Spangler and Smith have signed on to be the architects of the project.

Work is slated to begin in February, and the building is scheduled for occupancy in August 2013.

The board on Thursday also approved amending its application to the state government requesting little- to no-interest Qualified School Construction Bonds.

The district had planned to seek $115 million in bonds to build replacement facilities for E.T. Booth and Teasley Middle schools and to construct two new elementary schools.

The elementary schools are being scrapped, which reduces the bond issuance request to $81 million.

The board also voted on Thursday night to purchase one or two properties at undisclosed locations for undisclosed prices based upon staff's approval, provided the sites meet appraisal expectations.
comments (11)
« Citizen Jane wrote on Thursday, Mar 25 at 10:50 PM »
"The board also voted on Thursday night to purchase one or two properties at undisclosed locations for undisclosed prices based upon staff's approval, provided the sites meet appraisal " - Um....I'm sorry- WHAT?! Weren't we just talking about ways to cut costs! - let's cut costs by buying land at undisclosed locations and undisclosed prices. RIDICULOUS!
« Very concerned mom wrote on Monday, Feb 15 at 08:51 PM »
Why would the Pre-K program not be cut before we cut Kindergarten to half days? I put my son in Pre-K to help him get used to full days before starting Kindergarten next year. If Cherokee Co. or Little River decide to do half days, I will send my child to private Kindergarten. This is absurd!

« Hart Williford wrote on Friday, Feb 12 at 08:14 AM »
We need to go back to the Roy Barnes era where kids, teachers and our schools were a priority. Almost from the day Perdue was elected you could begin to see our educational focus move backwards.
« Seriously?? wrote on Wednesday, Jan 27 at 03:10 PM »
Michael Five is ALIVE!
« Mary Joe Fox wrote on Tuesday, Jan 26 at 07:11 PM »
I wish Dr P would have a way for employees to give him imput on ways to stop and cut cost, without the employees risking losing their jobs. If he could please, just please, see all the ideas from inside. So many things are reported by the lower end of the chain, and like any big companies, things reported goes swept under the rugs. We know you only hear what the management wants you to hear. Every employee is furloughed, not just teachers. Some only make poverty levels, but would love to share how money is waisted. Also, why not close the schools for couple days. Why not let the parents, kids, and public have to see what no tax money does. Why should they care when the school system keeps catering to them. They see no problem. They ask for more from the teachers, they want door to door bus service, that should be stopped. Let the drivers meet with the supervisors from each school to share where bus stops over lap. Why are buses going from one end of the county to another to transport to a Pre K. I live in Canton and a neighbor has a bus pick up a 3 yr old and drive to that new Little River. All this can't be the lottery. Get real parents this is everyones problem that attends schools. (even the non citizens)If not a citizen, why not no free school like we give them.
« Concerned tax payer wrote on Tuesday, Jan 26 at 12:57 PM »
Millions of tax payer dollars have been wasted over the past 10 years by not awarding school construction projects to the lowest responsible bidder. The $18.7 million elementary school recently awarded to Hardin Construction could have been awarded to Rick's Contracting for less than $18.1 million. That would have saved the school district over $600,000. This is just one of many cases where extra money was spent on construction to suite the superintendent's personal preferences. WHY?
« Informed Parent wrote on Monday, Jan 25 at 10:08 PM »
To "concerned parent" - A majority of our School Police Officers live within the county. The ones who do live out of county are required to park their police cars in-county and drive their personal vehicles home unless they have a valid need, i.e. the K-9 officer. Officers protect our schools 24-7 and are paid very little for the great value they provide. They are the only ones in the schools capable of protecting our children from threats from within and without. I would be more "concerned" about my child's safety in today's schools than where the police officer is driving his patrol car.
« zambony2 wrote on Sunday, Jan 24 at 03:14 PM »
Bet you wish you saved the several million dollars that you spent on the bus depot in north cherokee for teaching kids instead of parking ten buses.
« Frustrated Parent wrote on Saturday, Jan 23 at 10:10 PM »
How about the State give me 50% of what they claim to spend on each kid, and I'll homeschool my children. I understand the economy is bad, however, school has always taken last place on GA's priority list. Before the economy went south, we were already dealing with not enough teachers, too many students, not enough classrooms, etc etc etc.. Tell the GA Lottery to start giving the GA Department of Education what it is actually suppose to get.
« concerned parent wrote on Saturday, Jan 23 at 04:45 PM »
I do believe Dr. P gets a new vehicle to drive every year from school district funds. Perhaps he should drive one for a few years instead. Lots of money is wasted on our 6 head football coaches being on a 235 day "teaching??"contract. They are being paid for more days than all of our principals except those in high school. No school board funds should be given to the schools for high school sports/band travel. The parents and/or school should fund this. Most of the school police live outside of the district and drive a school police car to/from work resulting in unneeded travel expenses. Why don't we hire local ones? Also, isn't it funny how the community can rally to raise over 1 million dollars for Etowah football (turf) but I see no one rallying efforts to help save school employees who were let go last year. Gotta love the educational impact of that! One last thing....how about that new Etowah gym? The trailer classrooms just moved down the hill, but the echo in the gym sounds awesome!
« Michael Sinco wrote on Saturday, Jan 23 at 10:45 AM »
The state only pays for half-day kindergarten, yet CCSD forks out the bill for a complete day.

One teacher's thoughts on suggestions:

1. Not buying textbooks and school buses next year...done. We can easily go another year stretching our textbooks.

2. Some Elem. schools have 1.5 nurses. That could be reduced down to 1 (sadly).

3. Charging a fee for sports/extracurricular (and having the boosters reduce their fees). I coach a sport, so I know all about this. The fee would go to transportation and officials' fees. The boosters might have to go a year without buying warmups or practice unis, but it really could get to being a wash for parents.

Some unmentioned ideas...

1. Green campaigns at schools to conserve energy. Computers/overheads/lights left on overnight. Schools AC/Heat units left off except for 15 minutes around school hours. Making use of natural lighting. Etc.

2. 3-6 furlough days for employees next year.

3. End property tax exemption for seniors. According to the CC Tax Accessors, these exemptions cost the schools $16,233,152 in 2008. That is equal to 8.5 furlough days for ALL Cherokee County School District Employees. Seniors enjoy the benefits of a well educated society too.